Sunset Beach Shelter Island

Shelter Island, United States View on map
Editor's Pick

"The on-site bar serves house-made rosé, while rustic decor defines the guest rooms. Best for weekend couples, less so for anyone seeking quiet surroundings."

From US$ 663 US$ 596 per night
Save 10%
Check-in
9 Sept 2026
Check-out
10 Sept 2026
Guests
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0
  • Free cancellation
    on many rooms
  • No booking fees
    Pay at the hotel
  • Secure booking
    Your data is safe
  • Best price guarantee
    Found a better price?

Why guests choose Sunset Beach

  • Private Beach
    Guest-only shoreline access
  • French Restaurant
    Casual dining, local dishes
  • Signature Rosé
    House label at on-site bar
  • Complimentary Bikes
    Explore Shelter Island trails
  • Pet Grooming
    On-site pet care services
  • In-Room Massage
    Book treatments at your room

Overview

The 4-star beachfront Sunset Beach Shelter Island hotel gives quick access to Sunset Beach, situated approximately a 5-minute walk away. This Shelter Island hotel offers 20 rooms and amenities such as a restaurant.

The hotel is 2.7 miles from Founders Landing Park and 1.8 miles from East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation. An idyllic beach is around 20 minutes' walk from the accommodation. Guests will also appreciate the vicinity of West Neck Bay, located miles away. There is Shelter Island within 25 minutes' walk of this hotel.

The rooms at the property include an air conditioner, as well as media facilities like a flat-screen TV with satellite channels.

Sunset Beach is situated within easy reach of the Shelter Island hotel.

  • Check-in
    from 16:00 until 23:59
  • Check-out
    until 11:00
  • Hotel class
    4 stars
Sunset Beach
Our tips

Should you book Sunset Beach?

Perfect if you
  • Want to dine on-site - the hotel has a restaurant serving local dishes and signature cocktails.
  • Enjoy biking - the hotel encourages exploring Shelter Island by bike.
  • Appreciate a social atmosphere - the dining and bar areas are designed for mingling.
Maybe skip if you
  • Need breakfast included - the restaurant does not open for breakfast and is closed some days.
Best for
  • A lively party scene with DJ performances on summer weekends
  • On-site bar serving the hotel's own self-produced Rosé

Facilities of Sunset

General
  • Wi-Fi
  • Smoke detectors
Dining
  • Restaurant
  • Bar/ Lounge area
Room Amenities
  • Dressing area
  • Ironing facilities
  • Hair dryer
  • Flat-screen TV
  • Direct dial telephone
  • CD player
  • AM/FM alarm clock
  • Carpeted floor

Policies

Sunset Beach applies these conditions to all bookings.
Check-in / Check-out
Check-in
from 16:00 until 23:59
Check-out
until 11:00
Important info

Thank you for your feedback

Thank you for subscribing

Close
Check-in
9 Sept 2026
Check-out
10 Sept 2026
Guests
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0
Select the dates
to see the actual offers